Ready to throw an unforgettable wedding shower for your bestie? Well, move over the petit fours and cupcakes. It’s time to switch things up. Instead of serving the same ol’ wedding shower fare, try out these four new sweet treat ideas:

Pie assortment

Bring on the pies. Order mini or full sizes of apple, cherry, key lime, chocolate, or strawberry rhubarb from local favorites like the Gingham Daisy Pie Company in northwest Arkansas or Mickey’s Cakes & Sweets in Little Rock.

Cookies to-go

This may be our favorite idea yet. Create cute goodie bags with custom stickers with the bride and groom’s name and wedding hashtag and encourage guests to fill them with their favorite cookies. Offer classic chocolate chip, sugar, peanut butter or oatmeal raisin from TracyCakes, Chick-fil-A, American Pie Pizza or others. You can even step it up a notch and get them monogrammed.

Ice cream bar

Set up a self-serve ice cream bar and don’t hold back on the toppings! Provide your guests with whipped cream, M&Ms, Magic Shell, strawberries, Reese’s and more. Or, if you’re going healthy, try out a sorbet bar with fruity options from James at the Mill or TCBY.

Cinnamon rolls

Pass out warm cinnamon rolls on trays with mimosas for a brunch themed wedding shower or simply serve as-is. We highly recommend the Old Mill Bread’s jumbo cinnamon rolls or Cinnabon’s classic “Minibons.” Honestly, you can’t go wrong with either.

Let us know what sweet treats you decide to serve up by tagging us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. And remember, you can make your life easier by placing your order for any of the sweet treats above with Chef Shuttle. They even let you order months in advance so you can officially mark it off your to-do list!